Serial effects 1 Running head: SERIAL EFFECTS IN READING ALOUD Serial Effects in Reading Aloud can be Produced by Parallel Connectionist Models
نویسندگان
چکیده
Coltheart and Rastle (1994) and Rastle and Coltheart (1999) observe that their Dual Route Cascaded (DRC) model of single-word reading has a left -to-right grapheme-tophoneme correspondence mechanism, distinguishing it from connectionist models of word naming which possess no such serial mechanism. In the DRC an irregular grapheme to phoneme correspondence near the beginning of a word (e.g. chef), compared with one near the end of a word (e.g. glow), produces the most disruptive competing analysis to the early output of the lexical route, which takes time to generate its own output. Coltheart and Rastle showed the same behaviour with human subjects, and argued that this Position of Irregularity (PoI) effect is evidence against connectionist models of reading. Zorzi (2000) has shown that one connectionist model of naming, the Connectionist Dual Process model (Zorzi, Houghton & Butterworth, 1998), can simulate the PoI effect and he reanalyses the effect in terms of a confound between consistency and syllable position – a reanalysis that Rastle and Coltheart reject. We argue that the PoI effect can be expected to emerge from any simple connectionist network that takes fixation position into account, and we demonstrate that this is indeed the case with two computational experiments using different versions of such networks. We show that the PoI effect emerges most parsimoniously from a new model of word recognition, the split-fovea model, which is based on the precise vertical splitting of the human fovea.
منابع مشابه
When parallel processing in visual word recognition is not enough: new evidence from naming.
Low-frequency irregular words are named more slowly and are more error prone than low-frequency regular words (the regularity effect). Rastle and Coltheart (1999) reported that this irregularity cost is modulated by the serial position of the irregular grapheme-phoneme correspondence, such that words with early irregularities exhibit a larger cost than words with late ones. They argued that the...
متن کاملThe locus of serial processing in reading aloud: orthography-to-phonology computation or speech planning?
Dual-route theories of reading posit that a sublexical reading mechanism that operates serially and from left to right is involved in the orthography-to-phonology computation. These theories attribute the masked onset priming effect (MOPE) and the phonological Stroop effect (PSE) to the serial left-to-right operation of this mechanism. However, both effects may arise during speech planning, in ...
متن کاملThe cross-script length effect: further evidence challenging PDP models of reading aloud.
The interaction between length and lexical status is one of the key findings used in support of models of reading aloud that postulate a serial process in the orthography-to-phonology translation (B. S. Weekes, 1997). However, proponents of parallel models argue that this effect arises in peripheral visual or articulatory processes. The authors addressed this possibility using the special chara...
متن کاملSerial Order in Reading Aloud: Connectionist Models and Neighborhood Structure
Dual-Route and Connectionist Single-Route models of reading have been at odds over claims as to the correct explanation of the reading process. Recent Dual-Route models predict that subjects should show an increased naming latency for irregular words when the irregularity is earlier in the word (e.g. chef is slower than glow)-a prediction that has been connrmed in human experiments. Since this ...
متن کاملParallel vs Serial Issues in Reading Aloud: Evidence for Parallel Processing from a Computational Model of Japanese Kanji & Kana Nonword Reading
Lower nonword reading performance in the old version of parallel-distributed processing models in English was taken as evidence for the necessity of sequential components in reading aloud, but the later updates have resolved this issue without discarding the parallel processing principle. A model’s validity can be tested by cross-script extensions. On this point, an extension to Japanese kanji ...
متن کامل